Notes from the Portable

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Start Here!
  • Classroom Management
  • Poetry
  • Ideas for Writing Workshop
  • Terms of Use/Contact
  • FREE RESOURCE LIBRARY

How Adding a Little Mystery Can Create Classroom Management Magic

My Favorite Classroom Behavior Management Trick. 

The procedures have been taught, the students know your expectations, but you still find yourself repeating directions over and over again.  Does this sound familiar?  Here is how I discovered I could improve my classroom management with a little mystery.

Everyone (well almost everyone) loves games and little competition. With that in mind, I started using Mystery Students to get students meeting my expectations.  At the beginning of the school year I used this A LOT and by a lot, I mean any chance I got.

Here are simple steps to letting Mystery Students make Classroom Management Magic.  

1. Before you begin be sure your students know your policies, procedures, and expectations.

Make use of the first two weeks of school to really teach, reteach, and review these.  If you want to know more about this read The Ultimate Guide to Starting the School Year, The Beginners Guide to Starting the School Year, and Do They Know Your Expectations.

2. State the instructions or expectation (walk in a line, go to an assembly, turn in assignments, transition from one subject to another).  The list of instructions are endless.  Maybe you have one mystery student to use for the entire day.

3. Have a way to grab student names (popsicle sticks in a cup are my favorite). Draw out one name, but do not announce the name or show the students the name.  Just take a quick peek.

4. Then ask the students do what you have instructed.  (Walk to lunch, get ready for math, etc.)

5. Monitor the students as they meet you expectation.

How to use mystery students.

Now that the task is completed several things can happen.

a.  The student meets the expectation.  If the student met the the expectation, tell who the  mystery student is and give a small prize (sticker, school supply).  Now here is where it really pays off.  Also give them a tally for a class prize.  Have the class work as a team to collect tallies for a whole class reward.

b.  The student doesn’t meet the expectation.  NEVER tell the whole class who the mystery student is if they don’t meet the expectation.  Let’s say you were using the Mystery Student for walking to Music and the student was turning around, running her finger over bulletin boards, and then raced into Music which is not the expectation of the Music teacher.  Say, “We can’t get a tally this time.  The Mystery Student didn’t meet the expectations of myself or the Music teacher.  And we need to remember to always keep our hands by our sides so we don’t ruin the work of others.”  If you want to talk individually and privately with the student at a later time, then do so, but not in front of the class.

c.  Your class is just having an awful day.  It is a full moon or the wind won’t stop blowing.  Your normally calm students are bouncing off the walls, no one seems to be at their best and the class just needs a turn around.  Here is where your private peek can help.  Only you know who the Mystery Student is.  So turn the day around and find the one person who did something close to your expectations, make a big deal about it, give the class a tally and let the joy of this move your day in a better direction.

I hope this idea will add some fun and help students meet your expectations.  Want to learn more?

This book and planner has over 400 pages of tips, planning pages, and checklists for your best school year.  

Classroom Management eBook and Planner

Looking for more Classroom Management Ideas? 

Check out these other posts:  

Classroom Management Techniques for New Teachers from Vestals 21st Century Classroom

Building a Classroom Community with the Gypsy Teacher

Student-Centered Classrooms with Teaching Organized

Four Fun Way to Ensure Your Classroom Expectations are Met 

Ultimate Guide to Back to School 

The #1 Way to Improve Student Behavior

 

Click these links to follow me on Pinterest, Facebook, and Instagram for ideas, tips, and classroom management tricks.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

«
»

Filed Under: Classroom Management, back to school, New Teacher, Organization, Starting the School Year 13 Comments

Comments

  1. Jaya Hira says

    August 27, 2016 at 5:50 am

    This is awesome, and you are a genius. I am in the third week of school in a bilingual setting, and am so using this. Thanks!

    Reply
    • trammell13@gmail.com says

      August 27, 2016 at 10:36 am

      I am so happy that this can help! Have a fabulous school year!

      Jessica

      Reply
  2. Jayme Goubeaux says

    August 28, 2016 at 11:11 pm

    You mentioned this in the article above and I can’t find it. ” If you want to learn more about whole class rewards, read Why You Need to Build a Team in Your Classroom.” Is this posted somewhere that I am not seeing?

    Reply
    • trammell13@gmail.com says

      August 31, 2016 at 8:35 pm

      Thank YOU!!! I scheduled several posts since I went back to work this week and I messed up my schedule. I will change the date on that one so it comes out soon. So sorry for the confusion, but thank you for asking.

      Jessica

      Reply
      • Sheri Hardy says

        September 27, 2016 at 11:37 pm

        Whew! I thought it was me who missed it. I will look forward to the “Build a Team” post, if you could direct me to it. Thank you for the great ideas!

        Reply
  3. Autumn Willis says

    June 1, 2023 at 10:40 pm

    I loved your mystery student as a classroom management tool. I will definitely add this to my pre-k classroom. I like how you don’t tell the students if the mystery student is not on task. I like how it can be an individual reward plus a class reward. I believe this will help the students remind each other to make the right choices.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. The Ultimate Guide for Back to School: 29 Classroom Management Tips says:
    February 21, 2017 at 2:26 am

    […] I would also pick one stick from my name jar (keep it a secret) and then tell the class that they would get a class reward (tally mark to a class reward, something) if the mystery student followed the line expectations. To learn more about Mystery Students click here. […]

    Reply
  2. 6 Classroom Management Tips for an Amazing School Year! says:
    July 27, 2017 at 10:07 pm

    […] the mystery student is meeting the expectation.  Want more details on mystery students?  Read the article HERE or click the image below to learn […]

    Reply
  3. The Observation Ready Classroom - Tips for Classroom Observations says:
    October 21, 2017 at 7:53 am

    […] Mystery Students to have amazing behavior.  Read this article on Mystery Students.  Tell your students that you will have a mystery student anytime that someone is in the room […]

    Reply
  4. Hot Links- 7-25-18 | Mr. Bright's Blog says:
    July 25, 2018 at 4:05 pm

    […] HOW ADDING A LITTLE MYSTERY CAN CREATE CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT MAGIC– I saw a long term substitute at my site doing this great idea. […]

    Reply
  5. Classroom Management Techniques for New Teachers says:
    July 25, 2019 at 11:14 am

    […] How Adding a Little Mystery Can Create Classroom Management Magic […]

    Reply
  6. Student-Centered Classrooms Create Community - Teaching Organized says:
    July 25, 2019 at 2:02 pm

    […] a Classroom Community from Day 1Classroom Management Techniques for New TeachersHow Adding a Little Mystery Can Create Classroom Management MagicHow to Become a Classroom Behavior Management […]

    Reply
  7. How to become a PRO at Classroom Behavior Management - Teaching Dunn Simply says:
    July 25, 2019 at 8:59 pm

    […] How Adding a Little Mystery Can Create Classroom Management Magic […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search This Site

Copyright © 2026 · Web Design by Designs by Kassie

Copyright © 2026 · Adorn Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in